Create Your DRF Account
New to DRF?
Everything you could possibly
need in one place
Register
Don't have an account? Register Here
DRF Logo
06/30/2008 10:44AM

Mother Goose Justice?

By Steven Crist
  • Print
Tweet
Email

Should the determing factor in disqualifying a horse be a)whether a foul was committed or b)whether the foul affected the order of finish? If you believe in the former, Proud Spell deserved to be taken down from second to third in the Mother Goose Saturday. I believe in the latter, so I think it was a bad takedown that served neither parimutuel nor sporting justice.

Here's the race:

Forget about Proud Spell's awful trip -- the stumble at the start, the hesitant ride from Gabriel Saez as she gets trapped and finally shut off at the rail -- until she finally gets some daylight in deep stretch. She spurts past Never Retreat, though isn't quite clear of her when she comes out late and Never Retreat's rider checks.

Was that a foul? Yes. Did it affect the order of finish? Absolutely not. So why punish the bettors (I personally didn't have a nickel at stake on the decision) for a jockey error that did not change the outcome? The fairer thing to do is fine the rider, rather than the customers. Proud Spell drew $179k of a $206k place pool, and her disqualification produced the following wacky payoffs: Music Note paid $5.30 to win and $11.60 to place, and Never Retreat paid $20.00 to place. The dq also resulted in the redistribution of the entire $363,212 exacta pool, elevating the payout from around $8 to $36.40.

If there were any reasonable case that Never Retreat could have finished second, or if Hamsa had passed Never Retreat and the check had cost her third, Proud Spell should have come down. Instead, the technical recognition of a foul produced an unfair result. Some people believe that a foul is a foul is foul, but I would prefer to see the stewards exercise their judgment. Saez's share of the purse decreased from $5,000 to $2,500 with the dq -- why not just fine him $2500 instead of redirecting half a million in wagers?

  • Print



Most Popular

  • Stories
  • DRF Products
  1. 1.
    Wondrwherecraigis takes them gate to wire in Fire Plug
    Posted 01/29/2022 04:45PM
  1. 1.
    10-Card Formulator PP Plan
  2. 2.
    10-Card Classic PP Plan
  3. 3.
    DRF Plus One-Month Subscription
  4. 4.
    DRF Digital Newspaper
  5. 5.
    DRF Clocker Reports
Syndicate content Subscribe to this blog

DRFLogoFooter
DRF.com News Search
  • Horse Racing Events
    • Saratoga Meet
    • Kentucky Derby
    • Fountain of Youth Stakes
    • Preakness Stakes
    • Belmont Stakes
    • Triple Crown
    • More
  • Horse Racing News
    • Race of the Day
    • Track News
    • Top Headlines
    • Race Previews
    • Race Recaps
    • More
  • Tracks
    • Churchill Downs
    • Gulfstream Park
    • Belmont Park
    • Aqueduct
    • Saratoga
    • More
  • Handicapping & PPs
    • DRF Classic PPs
    • Formulator PPs
    • TimeForm US PPs
    • Daily Racing Program
    • DRF Picks
    • More
Get our free Newsletter, DRF Morning Line

Free Race-of-the-Day video analysis & PPs,DRF Bets Gameplan Play-of-the-Day, all the latest racing news and more.

Sign Up for Newsletter
  • Bet Now
  • Purchase PPs
  • DRF Sports
  • About
  • Betting 101
  • Handicapping 101
  • Help Center
  • Advertising
  • Contact
  • Policies
  • Sitemap
© Daily Racing Form. All rights reserved
Download DRF Bets on your smartphone
Don't miss the break! Follow DRF
© Daily Racing Form. All rights reserved